Local Chapters Judging Form Clarence H. Howard Memorial Judging FormPresented annually to the most outstanding established local chapters (chartered prior to January 1, 2025) with exceptional programming.Judges Name(Required) First Last Chapter Submitted(Required)State Submitted(Required)Rating Scale (for all statements)Please choose a number 1-5 for all statements. 1 = Strongly Disagree \ 5 =Strongly AgreeAREA 1: STRATEGY & DIRECTIONRate your agreement with each statement.The chapter clearly articulated a strategic vision and direction for the year(Required)The chapter’s Plan of Action was intentional, well-structured, and appropriate for its size and context.(Required)The goals identified by the chapter addressed meaningful needs of members and the community.(Required)The chapter demonstrated thoughtful planning rather than reactive or ad-hoc decision-making.(Required)AREA 2: PROGRAMMING & EXECUTIONRate your agreement with each statement.The chapter offered a well-rounded mix of programming (individual, community, economic, and/or international development).(Required)Programs were executed effectively and demonstrated clear follow-through.(Required)The chapter’s programming produced measurable or clearly described outcomes.(Required)The execution of programs reflected strong organization and leadership capacity.(Required)AREA 3: MEMBERSHIP & ORGANIZATIONAL HEALTHRate your agreement with each statement.The chapter demonstrated intentional efforts toward membership growth and/or retention.(Required)Membership strategies aligned with the chapter’s stated goals and activities.(Required)The chapter showed evidence of financial responsibility and sustainability.(Required)Financial decisions supported long-term organizational health rather than short-term gains.(Required)AREA 4: LEADERSHIP & MEMBER DEVELOPMENTRate your agreement with each statement.Chapter leadership effectively guided the organization throughout the year.(Required)Members were meaningfully engaged in leadership roles, projects, or decision-making.(Required)The chapter provided opportunities for leadership development and skill-building.(Required)Leadership actions contributed positively to chapter culture and morale.(Required)AREA 5: IMPACT & ALIGNMENTRate your agreement with each statement.The chapter created a meaningful impact within its local community.(Required)Chapter activities aligned clearly with the JCI mission, vision, and values.(Required)The chapter demonstrated relevance and visibility within its community or region.(Required)The chapter’s work reflected enterprising leadership and positive change.(Required)AREA 6: OVERALL ASSESSMENTRate your agreement with each statement.Overall, this submission represents an outstanding local chapter deserving of national recognition.(Required)The chapter's impact rises above that of a typical and comparable local chapter.(Required)This nomination is competitive at a national level.(Required)Overall Excellence of the Chapter(Required) 1- Not competitive at the national level 2- Below average submission 3- Solid, competitive chapter 4- Very strong chapter 5- Exceptional, national-caliber chapter Considering all criteria, how would you rate this chapter overall?Overall Comments(Required)Judges Attestation(Required)I reviewed this submission in full. I evaluated this project/program fairly and objectively. I applied the scoring criteria consistently and without bias. I attest that the above statements are true.
