C. William Brownfield Memorial Judging Form C. William Brownfield Memorial Judging FormThe C. William Brownfield Memorial Award recognizes new JCI members who, during their first year of membership, have demonstrated exceptional commitment, leadership potential, and alignment with the JCI mission and values. This award honors individuals whose early involvement shows meaningful impact on their local organization, active participation in JCI activities, and promise as enterprising young leaders. Judges should evaluate nominees based on impact on the local organization, community involvement, participation in JCI activities, leadership potential, and exemplification of JCI values, as outlined in the JCI USA Awards Manual.Judges Name(Required) First Last ChapterState(Required)Nominee Name(Required)Rating Scale (for all statements)Please choose a number 1-5 for all statements. 1 = Strongly Disagree \ 5 =Strongly AgreeAREA 1: ENGAGEMENT & PARTICIPATIONRate your agreement with each statement.The nominee demonstrated strong engagement during their first year as a JCI member.(Required)The nominee actively participated in projects, meetings, or chapter activities.(Required)The nominee sought opportunities to learn, grow, and contribute within the organization.(Required)The nominee’s level of involvement exceeded typical expectations for a new member.(Required)AREA 2: IMPACT ON THE LOCAL ORGANIZATIONRate your agreement with each statement.The nominee made meaningful contributions to their local organization.(Required)The nominee’s involvement positively impacted chapter operations, programming, or culture.(Required)The nominee took initiative to support the success of the organization.(Required)The nominee added clear value despite being new to JCI.(Required)AREA 3: COMMUNITY IMPACT & SERVICERate your agreement with each statement.The nominee contributed to projects or initiatives that benefited the local community.(Required)The nominee demonstrated an understanding of JCI’s role in creating positive community change.(Required)The nominee’s actions had a tangible or clearly described community impact.(Required)The nominee showed commitment to service and civic engagement.(Required)AREA 4: LEADERSHIP POTENTIALRate your agreement with each statement.The nominee demonstrated leadership potential during their first year of membership.(Required)The nominee showed initiative, responsibility, and follow-through.(Required)The nominee embraced opportunities to lead or support others.(Required)The nominee exhibited qualities consistent with enterprising young leadership.(Required)AREA 5: EXEMPLIFICATION OF JCI VALUESRate your agreement with each statement.The nominee exemplified JCI values through their actions within the organization.(Required)The nominee demonstrated professionalism, integrity, and ethical behavior.(Required)The nominee’s actions aligned with the JCI mission and vision.(Required)The nominee served as a positive ambassador for JCI.(Required)AREA 6: OVERALL ASSESSMENTRate your agreement with each statement.Overall, this nominee represents an outstanding new member deserving of national recognition.(Required)The nominee’s contributions exceeded expectations for a first-year member.(Required)This nomination is competitive at a national level.(Required)I would strongly recommend this nominee for recognition in this category.(Required)REQUIRED JUDGE FEEDBACKStrengths(Required)What stood out most about this nominee’s first year in JCI?Opportunities for Growth(Required)What areas could this nominee continue to develop as they progress in JCI?Overall Comments(Required)Judges Attestation(Required)I reviewed this submission in full. I evaluated this project/program fairly and objectively. I applied the scoring criteria consistently and without bias. I attest that the above statements are true.
